Billy vs. Evident (2026): COI Tracking for Construction

COI Tracking Comparison Updated November 2026 By the Billy Team 9 min read
Quick answer

Evident (also called Evident ID) is a multi-industry third-party risk and insurance verification platform for large enterprises in equipment rental, logistics, retail, the public sector and more. Billy is a construction-native COI tracking and compliance platform built for general contractors.

Choose Evident if you need insurance, identity, background and credential checks across many non-construction vendor types. Choose Billy if you’re a GC who needs endorsement-level COI review, Procore and construction ERP integrations, subcontractor prequalification, and the option of a fully managed compliance team.

Transparency note: This comparison is published by Billy. We’ve tried to be accurate and fair to Evident, including where it’s the better fit. Evident details come from Evident’s public website as of November 2026. If anything has changed, let us know and we’ll update it.

Billy vs. Evident at a glance

 BillyEvident
Built forConstruction: GCs, subcontractors, ownersMulti-industry: public sector, equipment rental, construction, logistics, manufacturing, retail, hospitality, financial services
Core focusCOI and compliance tracking for construction projectsThird-party risk management and insurance verification
Published pricingQuote-based (book a demo)Essential $15/vendor/yr · Pro $25/vendor/yr · Enterprise custom
Endorsement review✓Every plan, via the AI Review Assistant; human experts on the Managed plan–Included from the Pro tier up
Managed services✓Full Managed plan, or mix with self-service–Paid add-on on Pro and Enterprise
Procore integration✓Two-way sync plus Procore Side Panel✕Not listed on Evident’s site
Construction ERP / PM tools✓Autodesk, Trimble ProjectSight, Sage 300, Sage Intacct, Viewpoint Vista, CMiC, JD Edwards, Acumatica, Docusign–Salesforce, Origami Risk, Tyler Technologies, RentalMan, Texada; integrations and SSO are Enterprise-tier
Subcontractor prequalification✓Built in✕Not listed on Evident’s construction page
Vendor / broker upload✓Direct upload, no login required✓Branded vendor portal
Identity, background & MVR checks✕Not offered✓Available as add-ons
Best forGCs and construction firmsLarge enterprises verifying many vendor types

✓ included · – partial or tier-dependent · ✕ not offered or not listed. Evident details from evidentid.com, November 2026.

What is Evident?

Evident (evidentid.com, often searched as “Evident ID”) describes itself as an AI-powered supplier and third-party risk management platform. It automates COI collection and insurance verification, then layers on risk intelligence: pre-onboarding vendor snapshots, continuous monitoring for cancellations and lapses, peer requirement benchmarks, and concentration alerts such as a carrier downgrade affecting several vendors.

Evident’s scope goes well beyond insurance. It also verifies W-9s, contracts, hold harmless agreements, licenses, permits and business registrations, and offers criminal background checks, motor vehicle record (MVR) checks and e-signature as add-ons. It serves many industries and names customers such as United Rentals, Lowe’s, 7-Eleven, Amazon, MasTec and the County of San Diego. It lists SOC 2 Type II, GDPR and CCPA compliance.

What is Billy?

Billy is construction compliance software that collects, verifies and tracks certificates of insurance, W-9s, business licenses and other vendor documents in one place. It was built specifically for builders, with input from experienced construction professionals, and is used by 1,000+ construction GCs.

Billy’s AI Review Assistant checks each COI against your project requirements: coverage limits, expired policies, Additional Insured language, umbrella and workers’ comp requirements, and endorsements such as CG 20 10, CG 20 37, waiver of subrogation and primary/non-contributory wording. In most cases it reviews a COI in seconds and explains what’s missing and how to fix it. Teams can run Billy self-service, hand it to Billy’s Managed plan (insurance experts who review every certificate and endorsement as an extension of your compliance department), or mix the two.

Billy also includes subcontractor prequalification, free tools for subs (Insurance Wallet, a W-9 generator, lien waiver and warranty forms), and integrations with Procore, Autodesk, Sage, Viewpoint Vista, CMiC, JD Edwards and more.

Evident pricing (2026)

Evident is one of the few COI platforms that publishes list prices. Per its pricing page (November 2026):

PlanList priceProgram sizeKey inclusions
Essential$15 per vendor/year, billed annually200–1,000 third partiesBasic insurance types, unlimited users and documents, branded vendor portal, basic reporting
Pro$25 per vendor/year, billed annually500–10,000 third partiesAdds endorsements and additional insurance types, W-9s and business registrations, API and sandbox, dedicated CSM
EnterpriseCustom10,000+Adds contract risk assessment, permits and hold harmless agreements, SSO, integrations, embedded UX

Three things matter for contractors:

  • Endorsement checks start at Pro. Essential covers basic insurance types; endorsements are listed from Pro up. In construction, endorsements (Additional Insured, waiver of subrogation, primary/non-contributory) are usually the whole point of COI review.
  • Integrations and SSO are Enterprise-only. If you need compliance data flowing into other systems, budget for the custom tier.
  • Managed services cost extra. Outreach to unresponsive vendors is an add-on on Pro and Enterprise with no published price, and isn’t available on Essential.
Example: a GC with 600 active subcontractors on Evident Pro would pay about $15,000 a year at list price, before managed services or other add-ons. Evident notes that volume discounts are available.

Billy doesn’t publish list pricing; quotes depend on your program and whether you want self-service, managed, or both. Book a demo to get a number you can compare side by side.

Key differences between Billy and Evident

1. Construction depth vs. cross-industry breadth

Edge for GCs: Billy

Evident is built to verify many kinds of third parties (equipment renters, motor carriers, franchisees, suppliers) across many industries, and construction is one of nine industries it serves. Billy does one thing: construction compliance. That shows up in the details: project-level requirements, endorsement wording, payment workflows, prequalification, and the tools general contractors already use.

2. Endorsement-level COI review

Edge: Billy

A COI that shows the right limits can still leave you exposed if the Additional Insured endorsement doesn’t cover completed operations or the waiver of subrogation is missing. Billy’s AI Review Assistant checks CG 20 10, CG 20 37, waiver of subrogation and primary/non-contributory wording on every plan, and your team can chat with it to clarify requirements. On Evident, endorsement verification is part of the Pro tier and above. (Related: what a continuous damage exclusion means for GCs.)

3. Procore and construction ERP integrations

Edge: Billy

Billy syncs project and vendor data with Procore automatically (setup takes minutes), shows compliance status inside Procore through the Side Panel, embeds compliance tasks into ProcorePay workflows, and can send expired COI alerts in Procore. It also connects to Autodesk, Trimble ProjectSight, Sage 300, Sage Intacct, Viewpoint Vista, CMiC, JD Edwards, Acumatica and Docusign.

Evident’s listed integrations are Salesforce, Origami Risk, Tyler Technologies, RentalMan and Texada, plus open APIs, webhooks and custom integrations. Its site doesn’t list Procore or construction ERPs, and integrations are an Enterprise-tier feature.

4. Managed services vs. self-service

Edge: Billy

Billy offers a full Managed plan where insurance experts review every certificate and endorsement for you, a self-service option, or a mix across vendor segments. Evident leans toward self-configuration; managed outreach is a paid add-on on Pro and Enterprise.

5. Subcontractor experience

Edge: Billy

Subs and their brokers can upload documents to Billy directly, with no login required, and they get free tools like Insurance Wallet and a W-9 generator. Fewer hoops means faster responses and fewer chase emails for your team. See Billy for subcontractors.

6. Subcontractor prequalification

Edge: Billy

Billy includes prequalification in the same platform as COI tracking, so qualification and ongoing compliance live in one record (and subs pay nothing to prequalify; see who should pay for prequalification). Evident’s construction page focuses on insurance verification, monitoring and e-signatures and doesn’t list prequalification.

7. Identity, background and credential checks

Edge: Evident

If you need criminal background checks, motor vehicle records or credential verification alongside COIs, Evident offers them as add-ons and Billy doesn’t.

Where Evident is the stronger choice

To be fair, Evident wins in some situations:

  • Identity, background and MVR checks alongside insurance verification.
  • Non-construction programs. Equipment rental, logistics, retail, franchise and public-sector programs are core Evident markets.
  • Very large, global vendor bases. Evident cites verifications in 65 languages across 140 countries and Enterprise plans for 10,000+ third parties.
  • Transparent list pricing. Evident publishes per-vendor prices, which makes early budgeting easier.

Billy or Evident: which should you choose?

Choose Billy if…

  • You’re a GC, construction manager or specialty contractor
  • You need endorsement-level review without upgrading tiers
  • You run Procore, Sage, Viewpoint, CMiC, JD Edwards or Autodesk
  • You want the option of a fully managed compliance team
  • You want prequalification and COI tracking in one platform

Choose Evident if…

  • You manage many vendor types outside construction
  • You need identity, background or MVR checks alongside insurance
  • You run a global or 10,000+ vendor program, often on Salesforce or Origami Risk

Evident alternatives for construction

If you’re evaluating Evident alternatives for a construction company, these comparisons and guides may help:

Getting ready for an audit? Grab the free 2026 audit-ready checklist or read our customer case studies.

Frequently asked questions

Is Evident the same as Evident ID?

Yes. Evident’s website is evidentid.com, and the company and product are commonly called both “Evident” and “Evident ID.”

How much does Evident cost?

Per Evident’s pricing page (November 2026), Essential is $15 per vendor per year and Pro is $25 per vendor per year, both billed annually. Enterprise is custom. Managed services and other add-ons cost extra.

Does Evident integrate with Procore?

Evident’s website doesn’t list a Procore integration. Its listed integrations are Salesforce, Origami Risk, Tyler Technologies, RentalMan and Texada, plus APIs and custom integrations on Enterprise. Billy integrates with Procore natively, including the Procore Side Panel.

Does Evident offer managed COI services?

Yes, as a paid add-on on the Pro and Enterprise plans. Billy offers a full Managed plan where insurance experts review every certificate and endorsement.

Is Billy or Evident better for general contractors?

For most GCs, Billy, because it’s built for construction workflows: endorsement review, Procore and ERP integrations, prequalification and managed compliance. Evident is a better fit for multi-industry enterprises that also need identity and background checks.

Can I switch from Evident to Billy?

Yes. Billy’s onboarding includes a kickoff call, a review of your compliance standards, product setup and integrations, and team training before go-live. Talk to our team to plan the move.

Does Billy check endorsements like CG 20 10 and CG 20 37?

Yes. Billy’s AI Review Assistant flags missing CG 20 10, CG 20 37, waiver of subrogation and primary/non-contributory endorsements, along with incorrect limits, expired policies and missing Additional Insured language.

Stop chasing COIs

See how Billy handles COI tracking, endorsement review and Procore sync for your projects, in one demo.

Book a demo Billy for GCs

Similar Posts